Sometimes Ejaculation is a Bad Idea
Posted at 08:42:00
on Thu, March 30th 2006 by graham
in:
in the news
observations
reading
writing
My first reaction upon reading the news that the latest Harry Potter book had won the book of the year award was 'oh, please.' Then I read a bit further down the article and discovered that it was a publicly-voted win and thought 'oh, well that's alright then.'
It's not that I don't like Harry Potter. They're perfectly enjoyable and for the most part the story is pretty good, but there are things that just grate on me, particularly about the last few books in the series. Perhaps it's the success of the franchise that's done it (although if I remember correctly some of the problems were there from the beginning), but some of the faults with the stories are down to poor writing and, less forgivably, poor editing. I'm still at a loss to explain why someone armed with a blue pencil and a bit of a backbone didn't remove "'Snape!' Slughorn ejaculated" from Half Blood Prince. I wonder if Rowling has garnered the same status with editors that Tolkien had: Thou shalt not edit.
Or perhaps I'm just a bitter and twisted wannabe writer thinking 'I could do better than that.' Yes, that seems more likely. It doesn't help that the WordPress control panel seems to be running rather slowly this morning.

